PDA

View Full Version : Confusion over whether terror suspects are Muslim, Christian or a mix


AlonzoMourning23
06-24-2006, 12:57 AM
Mix of Christian, Muslim

McNulty said the goal is "prevention through prosecution." Rather than allow a genuine threat to take shape, he said, investigators move in as soon as there is sufficient evidence to prosecute.

"Today's example is a good example of that approach," he said, referring to the Florida case. McNulty said 261 people have been convicted or pleaded guilty in "terrorism or terrorism-related cases" since the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks.

Neighbors said at least some of the men were in a religious group they called the Seas of David that appeared to mix Christian and Muslim beliefs. They wore uniforms bearing a star of David and met for Bible study, prayer and martial arts practice in a one-story warehouse in the heart of the predominately Haitian section of Miami's impoverished Liberty City neighborhood.

Workers in Bar-B's Grocery next door said they were always quiet and polite when they stopped in to buy drinks. But at least five of the men had been arrested previously on assault, drug and weapons charges, according to Dade County records.

In addition to Batiste, 32, who was known as "Brother Naz" or "Prince Manna," authorities identified others born in the United States as Burson Augustin, 21; Rotschild Augustine, 22; Naudimar Herrera, 22; and Stanley Grant Phanor, 31. The two Haitian-born defendants are Patrick Abraham, 27, and Lyglenson Lemorin, 31.

All appeared briefly in court in Miami on Friday except Phanor, who was being held in jail for violating his probation on an earlier charge, and Lemorin, who was arrested in Atlanta. At Phanor's neatly landscaped house on Friday, his relatives cried as they answered a reporter's questions about him.

"This is tearing this family to pieces," said Phanor's mother, Elizene Phanor. She described her son as a skilled construction worker.

"My son would wake up every morning and say he loves Jesus," said Phanor. "Stan is my son, my friend, my life, and if he dies, I die with him."


http://www.chron.com/disp/story.mpl/front/3997622.html

Relatives of some of the men denied that they were Islamic radicals and said that they were non-violent, Christian Bible-worshippers dedicated to preventing crime in the sometimes troubled neighbourhood.

One man in Liberty City, who identified himself only as Brother Corey and said that he was also a member of the Seas of David group, said that it was a peaceful movement that combined the teachings of both Islam and Christianity and helped the local community.

"We negotiate to help the peace; we try to bring as many brothers in to help them out," he protested. "We study and we train through the Bible, not only physically but mentally ... we help put people in the right direction. We are not terrorists."

http://news.scotsman.com/international.cfm?id=922882006

The family of Phanor, who according to the indictment calls himself "Brother Sunni," told reporters in Miami he was innocent of all charges and was a practicing Roman Catholic, not a Muslim.

"They all call themselves brothers and they well-mannered," said his older sister, Marlene Phanor. "All they was trying to do was clean up the community. We are Catholic. He's Catholic." She said the family attends St. Mary's Catholic Church in Miami.

Sylvain Plantin, a cousin of Phanor's, said he was involved in a religious group called "Mores," which met to read the Bible. (Watch as one of the group's members says they are not terrorists -- 6:52)

"They don't eat meat, they don't smoke, they don't drink, and they train highly intensively," he said. "The warehouse is the temple where they all go and pray and meditate."

The windowless warehouse in Liberty City, a predominantly black and low-income area of Miami, was one of several places searched by FBI agents Thursday. Authorities said the men had been living there since March.

Neighbors said the men, who wore turbans, caused no problems but seemed odd.


http://www.cnn.com/2006/US/06/23/miami.reax/index.html

I find this interesting. Many are describing them as muslim, many as a blend of christianity/Islam, and only a very few as christian. Though every article that talks about the group never mentions anything Islamic about the "Seas of David". Bible study, Jesus talk, never any mention of the Quran, Muhammed or anything else in the articles I've read. It seems that they may simply be a very radical elements of a fringe Christian group that felt that the best way to accomplish their goal was to work with the most established and ruthless major terrorist group.

CheesyMuslim
06-24-2006, 09:03 AM
Sorry bout that,

1. But didn't the FBI fake being Al Qaeda with these men and they asked for help from them to the tune of 50k?
2. I am sure these men if they planned for an attack on America were Islamic Based, no matter how the Liberal Media wants to spin this.
3. The details will come out, while the Liberal Media will sugar coat it before hand and after.

Regards,
SirJamesofTexas

Old Corps Gunny
06-24-2006, 10:49 AM
From interviews and stories on the news, it seems that Phanor was the only one of the group who had a steady job; it also seems that he just got sucked into a bunch of al Qaeda wannabes. However, all members of the group took an oath of allegiance to al Qaeda and Osama bin Laden. Further, residents of the neighborhood stated these guys claimed they had given their lives over to Allah; that definitely sounds like they are claiming to be Muslims to me. Regardless of religious affiliation, the fact remains they planned to commit terrorist acts in this country and asked for material and financial aid from a person they believed to be a representative of al Qaeda to accomplish these acts. That makes them terrorists, everything else is irrelevant.

AlonzoMourning23
06-24-2006, 12:17 PM
It isn't irrelevent. Muslims, and those mistaken for them, have been attacked, mosques have been vandalized, and an entire religion deemed terrorist by many people. A terrorist attack done by christians, or a primarily christian group, challenges the stereotype.

But if you want help committing a terrorist act, but lack the know how or connections, then you have two easily accesable choices, you go to Al-Qaeda or the IRA. The IRA hasn't involved itself with arming or aiding terrorists for a while, so that leave Al Qaeda. Sure, you can go to other groups, but they'd be more difficult to contact and likely lack the know how.

Also it's a popular misconception that Allah is an Islamic term. It is the Arabic word for God and is used in Arabic translations of the bible, and is used by Arabic speaking Christians, Muslims, Jews etc. There is debate among scholars whether the term should be translated, and some english Qurans change it to God while some keep it as Allah.

The use of the term Allah and the fact they were wearing turbans can easily explain why locals thought they were Muslim. They did not attend local Mosques and it does seem very likely that they were not Muslims in the traditional sense. I think they're a radical Christian group, but at this point anything beyond saying they're not pure Muslim is largely a guess.

BoogyMan
06-24-2006, 12:27 PM
Alonzo,

You are correct that the word allah pre-dates islam. Allah was incorporated by converts from pre islam pagan arab religions. However your point about a challenge to the stereotype doesn't seem to hold much water.

These men were caught because they solicited assistance from someone they though was a member of Al Queda, a known radical islamist group.

I guess a better way to describe these men is radical islamist wannabes.

AlonzoMourning23
06-24-2006, 12:51 PM
But the question is where they attempting to work with them because they were beneficial, or did they have a common ideological basis?

At this point, I see no reason to think they're Muslim. The question, in my mind, is are they a Christian group that adopts some regional traditions (giving the appearance of Islam), or a pseudo Christian group that blends Islam with it.

PittsburghAfterDark
06-24-2006, 12:56 PM
Anything to deflect blame from the overtly terrorist Islamofascists huh 'zo?

BoogyMan
06-25-2006, 02:15 PM
But the question is where they attempting to work with them because they were beneficial, or did they have a common ideological basis?

At this point, I see no reason to think they're Muslim. The question, in my mind, is are they a Christian group that adopts some regional traditions (giving the appearance of Islam), or a pseudo Christian group that blends Islam with it.


Hi Alonzo,

Maybe I am missing the point you are trying to make, but the common thread is still Islam, there doesn't seem to be a way to logically exclude Islam at this point.

Nitrus
06-25-2006, 02:21 PM
Why does it matter what religion they are? The point is, they are disgracing their religion, and using "jihad" as an excuse to take lives, which is no way to use a religion, a religion is to worship your god, someone you feel close too, and a group of people who share your beliefs.

-N

CheesyMuslim
06-25-2006, 02:51 PM
Sorry bout that,

1. But in Islam its okay to lie to outsiders, kill them if you want to and destroy their way of life as a matter of basic Islamic Principle, and replace it with theirs.
2. That's what I see, does anyone see what I see?

Regards,
SirJamesofTexas

Old Corps Gunny
06-26-2006, 07:36 AM
The original story is about a group of mostly home-grown terrorists arrested in Miami. I stated earlier it was irrelevant what religion they were, the important fact was that they were plotting to commit terrorist acts in the United States. Your response about mosques being vandalized, Muslims attacked, and Islam being vilified has nothing to do with this group; these actions were taking place long before these wannabes ever got together, and it was in response to the attack of 9/11. Further, regardless of the etymological origins of the word Allah, in present context when someone states he has given his life over to Allah, one infers he is referring to Islam. I don't know any Christians who have used the word "Allah" when referring to God. By the way, chesswarsnow, the moderate Muslims detest the radical perversion of the Koran. I think you are referring to the doctrine of the "takfiri" who consider anyone (including Muslims) who do not share their beliefs as outsiders and legitimate targets.

AlonzoMourning23
06-26-2006, 11:16 AM
Allah is used by Arab speakers, even non-Muslims. But I'm not sure how people who don't go to Mosques, study primarily the bible etc. are to be considered Muslim.