PDA

View Full Version : Male victims of domestic violence


AlonzoMourning23
04-06-2006, 07:18 PM
This is an issue that doesn't get nearly enough attention. And any attention that doesn't involve mocking the guy is always a bonus. Probably the only time I've ever seen it dealt with with even a remotely sympathetic tone was an episode of Titus. I've never seen a mainstream media article on it until now. By that I mean articles that deal with it as domestic violence, as they would with women, instead of simply violence.

SARASOTA, Florida (CNN) -- When I met Leo, Paul and Tom at a domestic violence shelter here, it was hard to believe the three men's story: that they were victims of physical abuse at the hands of their female partners.

Leo, who is about 6 feet tall and said he weighed more than 200 pounds at the time of the abuse, said his girlfriend terrorized him while he was recovering from a heart transplant.

"She would throw things, she would absolutely throw things, one time she did grab my throat and was screaming in my face," he said.

Another time, Leo said, she pulled a knife on him, but he suspected she was just trying to scare him.

Tom said his ex-wife would fly off the handle without notice. He said he had to lie when co-workers noticed scratches on his body, saying "my hands were so clawed by her, at work a day later I would be writing something down, and someone would say 'Oh, you must have a mean cat,' I'd say 'Yeah, a mean cat.' What am I supposed to say?"

Tom's wife was arrested and pleaded guilty to assault.

Tom said while sitting in a courtroom during his divorce, he realized he was a victim of abuse.

"I looked up, and I see a poster saying 'Are you a victim of domestic violence?' And I start reading the questions, and tears started coming down. I said, 'damn.' "

Paul, who works for a cement company, said his wife would attack him when he got home from work.

"She'd come running at me like a wild animal, both hands and arms swinging, I think she had her eyes closed half the time," he said.

According to a police report, Paul attacked his wife and threatened to kill her, but he said that is a lie.

"She came running up to me with a knife, and I end up doing six months over it," he said.

CNN's efforts to contact Paul's ex-wife were unsuccessful.

All three men said they were reluctant to call police. Leo said he thinks in the case of a dispute, an officer would believe a woman's story over a man's.

"Whether it happened or not, if she signs that affidavit, you're on your way to jail, you're on your way to jail, no investigation no anything."

All three men have left the women they say abused them.

Mary Thoroman, a detective with the North Point, Florida, Police Department, said she is seeing more male victims of domestic violence than ever before.

"Typically it's the throwing of objects, a lot of scratching, a lot of face scratching, neck scratching, even chest, but objects being thrown is very, very common," she said.

After meeting the three men, I interviewed Darlene Hilker, a woman who admits to assaulting her husband. Hilker said she was arrested after an argument spun out of control, and "I grabbed my husband's genitals, that's what I was arrested for."

Hilker was sentenced to 16 weeks of counseling at the Domestic Abuse Shelter Homes in Englewood, Florida.

The executive director at DASH, Donna LeClerc, said her group is dealing with more and more cases of women abusing their mates, though Department of Justice statistics show spousal abuse arrests nationwide have dropped significantly during the past decade.

"Men have gotten the point that it's not OK to do those things, but somehow it's turned around, and it's OK for women to do those things," LeClerc said.

Hilker said her anger would build and build until she couldn't control it. She also said other woman are feeling the same frustration, and are resorting to violence.

"There's a lot of women with a lot of anger, and they are letting it go," Hilker said. "It's not just husbands beating up wives; women can fly off, too."



http://www.cnn.com/2006/US/04/06/btsc.rowlands.batteredmen/index.html

Most statistics I've seen suggest domestic abuse of men ranges anywhere between a quarter the rate of women, to equal the rate. The main problems are it either goes unreported, and/or men don't recognize it as such. For example, a man whose wife pulled a knife on him often won't attach that label to it, even though the effects of such violence aren't significantly different.

PittsburghAfterDark
04-06-2006, 10:13 PM
7 years ago I had a girlfriend that practically lived with me. You know how it happens, she doesn't "live" with you as in she has nowhere else to go because you're sharing a lease, bought a house together but you spend so much time together you might as well transfer mail to one residence or the other.

Long story short she had been in a car accident months before I met her and had gotten hooked on prescription pain killers. She ended up doctor shopping prescriptions. Didn't matter if it was a dentist, neurologists for "migranes", GP's, family practice physicians for this ailment or another. If she could get pills out of it she'd lie to get them.

Of course I didn't know this when I met her.

One Monday night she says she needs to get a prescription refilled. Unfortunately the same thing was said Friday night and she had gotten 30 something pills. Uh oh, I said, this is big trouble. So of course an argument ensues, it becomes heated, it becomes physical when I refuse to take her to the pharmacy or pay to have them delivered. She's going absolutely ballistic.

Three calls went to 911 that night after repeated suicide threats. I never did call about being assaulted, her attacks were well, pathetic. They wouldn't take her for observation, the medics couldn't take her anywhere if she wasn't willing to go and she was clearly a danger to herself and others. I even ended up taking a shotgun to my neigbors and left it with him for the night for fear of what she might be capable of.

Finally a pair of cops showed up, mixed gender partners. I remember sitting out on my front porch with the female cop trying to make small talk and shaking like a fig leaf smoking a cigarette because I'd never experienced behavior like this from anyone, let alone a girlfriend. The woman made the mistake of yelling and cursing at the male cop and throwing a full Coke can at him. End of story, she was removed and taken home.

Next day she tries to off herself on an overdose of stashed painkillers. Trust me when I say there's not much that can shake you relationship wise after a night like that then seeing someone in the emergency room with a mouthful of black teeth, lips and tongue from having to ingest charcoal to absorb an attempted pill OD.

There's little anyone can do if someone is bent on self-destruction or destructive behavior excpet move themselves out of the situation. I truly feel for men and women that are trapped by finances, circumstances or just being mentally locked into abusive relationships. It doesn't discriminate by age, education, income, race, religion or anything else.

Some people just need professional help and won't seek it.

Nitrus
04-07-2006, 10:53 AM
I think that the law is too leneant for women, if a girl gets drunk and has sex, and doesn't remember it or regretted doing it, she would report it as a rape and the guy would go down. (not all women, but some)

Plus there is no sympathy for men who claim they are abused by women, but lo and behold, if a women claims abuse, they get a whole department of detectives onto the case, and put the guy down for years, even if hes innocent.

That is not fair, and its not justice. The all famous scales of justice should have labels either side, one saying male, one saying female, with one of the scales balancing towards the female, that would be a better depiction of the law.

Sorry for that rant, it just annoys me, some guys I know don't like sleeping with people they've just met, they are scared of getting accused of rape.

-N